"CAFTA: Opportunity and Growth in Our Neighborhood"

Prepared Remarks By
Eugene Schreiber, Managing Director
World Center of New Orleans

CAFTA LUNCHEON FORUM
(Central American Free Trade Agreement)

Held on Wednesday, July 13 
At the Petroleum Club of Lafayette, Louisiana

Sponsored by Le Centre International de Lafayette

United States, Costa Rica, the Dominican Republic, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, and Nicaragua


Thank you, Philippe, and thanks to Le Centre International for organizing this timely forum. I am pleased to be here to discuss a multitude of opportunities for new business development right in our neighborhood. 

In this instance, however, I am not referring just to St. Martinville or Lake Charles or even our neighboring states of Texas, Arkansas, or Mississippi. Instead, I am referring to our closest international neighbors: Canada, Mexico, and the Central American countries of Guatemala, Honduras, El Salvador, Costa Rica, and Nicaragua, plus the Dominican Republic in the Caribbean.

One year ago, those five Central American countries, the Dominican Republic, and the United States signed a comprehensive free trade agreement, often referred to as CAFTA. The agreement negotiated by the Bush administration with those countries has been submitted to the U.S. Congress for approval. On June 30 it was approved by the Senate and is awaiting a final vote in the House. I will discuss CAFTA and its main provisions shortly.

First, though, let's take a quick look at the United States' trade growth with each of these international neighbors - Canada, Mexico, and Central America - whose principal cities are located only 1,000-1,500 miles from Louisiana, which places them within just three hours' direct flying time.

Canada has long been the United States' top export market worldwide and Mexico has moved up to the number two position. It may surprise you to learn that despite their relatively small size, the six CAFTA economies together represent an important export market for U.S. goods and services. In fact, in 2004 the CAFTA region, at $16 billion, ranked as the U.S.'s 12th largest export market, which was a greater volume of U.S. export sales than to vastly more populated and industrialized Russia, India, and Indonesia combined.

As for Louisiana exports to those countries, Mexico is now the state's third largest market, with $1.9 billion of sales in 2004 (after Japan and China), while Canada is fourth with $1.4 billion, and the CAFTA region ranks a close fifth with $1.2 billion. It also may surprise you to know that Louisiana's exports to the CAFTA countries in 2004 were equal to the state's exports to Germany, the United Kingdom, France, and Italy combined. In comparison with other U.S. states, Louisiana ranked first in agricultural exports and fourth in total merchandise exports to the CAFTA countries last year.

Broken down by industry, the top Louisiana exports to the CAFTA market in 2004 were agricultural products, processed foods, petroleum and coal, chemicals, paper, machinery, and transportation equipment.

The prospects for further growth of Louisiana's exports to the CAFTA region are excellent. In fact, I believe Louisiana is better positioned than any state in the country to take advantage of CAFTA's benefits. I also firmly believe that the potential benefits of CAFTA to the Louisiana economy are the greatest of any of the seven free trade agreements that the U.S. has signed since NAFTA - the North American Free Trade Agreement with Canada and Mexico - went into force in 1994.

With respect to NAFTA, let's take a look at the results to date for the U.S. and Louisiana and see how we have fared in our trade with Canada and Mexico under this historic agreement. Since it took effect, U.S. exports to the NAFTA market have doubled from $142 billion in 1993 to $300 billion in 2004, while Louisiana's exports to Canada and Mexico have more than tripled during that period, going from $946 million to $3.3 billion. The state's export sales to Mexico alone have almost quadrupled, rising from $501 million in 1993 to $1.9 billion in 2004. And as a share of its total worldwide exports, Louisiana's sales to the NAFTA region have jumped from 6% in 1993 to 17% in 2004.

Now let's turn to CAFTA, where accelerated trade results are also expected if this agreement is approved. CAFTA was signed by the six countries and the United States one year ago, and all the respective legislatures must approve it to take effect; Guatemala, Honduras, and the Dominican Republic have already done so. In the United States, both Houses of Congress must approve CAFTA in an up-or-down vote with no amendments. The Senate did so on June 30 by a vote of 54 to 45, and now it has moved to the House of Representatives, where it is expected to be voted on soon.

The basic objective of CAFTA is to eliminate tariffs and other trade barriers and expand regional opportunities for the manufacturers, workers, consumers, farmers, ranchers, and service providers of the participating countries. At the moment the playing field is not level, however. The CAFTA countries already enjoy duty-free access into the United States for 80% of their exports (99% for agricultural products) under the Caribbean Basin Initiative and other unilateral preference programs, while U.S. goods exported to the CAFTA countries face significant tariffs and other barriers.

The CAFTA agreement will rectify this imbalance and open up the CAFTA markets to U.S. goods, services, and farm products. In fact, the tariffs on more than 80% of U.S. exports of consumer and industrial products and 50% of our agricultural products exported to the CAFTA countries will be duty-free immediately upon implementation of the agreement, with most remaining duties phased out over 10 years (up to 15-20 years on certain agricultural products).

The best prospects for Louisiana exports to the CAFTA market include chemicals, plastics, paper, industrial machinery, transportation equipment, processed food, rice, cotton, soybeans, meat, and poultry products.

As noted earlier, I believe Louisiana stands to benefit from CAFTA more than any state in the country because of our geographic proximity to the region and also because of Louisiana's magnificent deepwater port system. This system is the world's largest port complex in terms of total waterborne commerce and is connected to over 30 Midwestern states. The Mississippi River is truly the Avenue of the Americas, an awesome water highway leading straight south to Mexico, Central America, and South America.

International trade and transportation have been the lifeblood of Louisiana for nearly 300 years. Trade helps grow our economy, supports well-paid jobs, and lowers prices for consumers. Over 3,000 companies in Louisiana are currently engaged in exporting, most of them small and medium-size enterprises. Dr. Tim Ryan, now Chancellor of the University of New Orleans, estimated in a 2001 study for the Ports Association of Louisiana, that Louisiana's maritime industry accounts for over 240,000 jobs, or about one in eight in the state, and has an economic impact exceeding $29 billion.

In a separate study for the Port of New Orleans in 2004, LSU economist Jim Richardson projected that the passage of CAFTA will generate new business sales for Louisiana of up to $338 million and up to 2,700 new jobs.

One need only look around this state to see the wide range of opportunities for our manufacturers, our farmers, our other businesses, our banks and other providers of international trade services, our ports, our universities, our medical centers, our tourism industry, and many other sectors of the Louisiana economy.

At the same time, we understand the concerns of the domestic sugar industry and their fear that this agreement and the small increases in imported sugar granted to the CAFTA countries will lead to more free trade agreements that include sugar. However, the Bush administration has made it clear that this agreement stands on its own and is not a template for future U.S. free trade agreements with other countries. 

Under the terms of CAFTA an additional 109,000 metric tons of sugar from the CAFTA countries would be allowed into the U.S. market of 10 million tons in the first year of the agreement (about 1% of domestic consumption), which would grow slowly to 153,000 tons  over 15 years (1.7% of consumption). Most analysts predict that CAFTA will have little impact on the sugar industry given these relatively small amounts of additional imported sugar and other safeguards for sugar that are built into the agreement and the U.S. sugar program in prior legislation.

On balance, we believe that CAFTA offers a multitude of benefits and opportunities for the United States and Louisiana to establish new business alliances with our longstanding friends and neighbors in Central America and the Dominican Republic. This bold initiative by the President deserves approval by Congress. We therefore urge the Louisiana members of the House of Representatives to vote in favor of its passage.


CAFTA Luncheon Forum
(Central American Free Trade Agreement)

Held on Wednesday, July 13 
At the Petroleum Club of Lafayette, Louisiana

Sponsored by Le Centre International de Lafayette

Moderator:

Philippe Gustin, International Trade Manager
Le Centre International de Lafayette

Speakers:

  • Eugene Schreiber, Managing Director
    World Trade Center of New Orleans
     

  • James H. Simon, General Manager
    American Sugar Cane League, Thibodaux
     

  • Jamie Warshaw, CEO
    Farmers Rice Milling Co., Lake Charles
     

  • John T. Hyatt, Vice President
    The Irwin Brown Company, New Orleans
     

  • Robert M. Landry, Marketing Director
    Port of New Orleans